Welcome to the D&O Insurance Monthly Pulse, our monthly roundup of the most important news, trends, and conversations shaping the Directors & Officers liability insurance landscape worldwide.
September brought three developments with direct implications for D&O: a proposed change to the US shareholder-proposal regime, further growth in AI-related litigation and early questions about whether the pricing cycle may be changing. AI risk advanced on three fronts: business performance, board oversight and product promises. Stephen Sills’ market-cycle perspective also offers a timely reminder about underwriting discipline.
Outside the US, Europe gained a new pan-European D&O facility. France and Germany clarified who may bring claims against directors and when cover may be rescinded; Canada certified a crypto class action; and reporting on WTW’s 2027 outlook indicates that financial lines in France remain soft.
Ten stories this time. Each one ends with a line on why it matters and includes the LinkedIn post and the people behind it, so you can follow the conversation where it is happening.
United States
1) The SEC proposes to rescind Rule 14a-8: shareholder proposals head to the states
For decades, Rule 14a-8 has let qualifying shareholders put their proposals in the company’s own proxy statement at almost no cost. On 16 September the SEC proposed to rescind it altogether. Chairman Paul Atkins argues that the rule goes beyond the Commission’s authority under Section 14(a) and intrudes on state corporate law. The release adds that several of the rule’s original justifications ‘have not been substantiated in practice’.
The package also proposes amendments to Rule 14a-4(c) on discretionary voting and would modernise proxy solicitation. The comment period runs for 60 days after publication in the Federal Register. Cooley expects any final rescission to face substantial litigation and Rule 14a-8 to remain in force through the 2027 proxy season.
Dave Lynn, former Chief Counsel of the SEC’s Division of Corporation Finance, put it well on The Corporate Counsel: rescission does not end shareholder proposals, ‘just an end to relatively easy and costless shareholder proposals’. Proponents would have to satisfy company advance-notice bylaws and run their own solicitations. Cooley expects activism to move toward ‘vote no’ campaigns against directors, proxy contests and litigation. Delaware may also have to decide whether shareholders have an inherent right to submit precatory proposals.
Why it matters: If the low-cost channel for shareholder proposals closes, activism is likely to shift toward individual directors through vote-no campaigns, proxy contests and litigation. That could bring governance pressure more directly into D&O territory.
Sources: Dave Lynn’s post on LinkedIn · SEC press release · Cooley: what comes next
People behind the stories: Dave Lynn, Meredith Ervine, Liz Dunshee
2) AI in court: CVS must face investor claims over AI-driven performance
Our August issue measured the AI litigation wave. September shows a court letting one of those cases through. On 27 August the Southern District of New York partially denied CVS Health’s motion to dismiss a securities class action, allowing key investor claims about the company’s use of AI to proceed.
As Sarah Abrams explains in The D&O Diary, this is not classic ‘AI-washing’, where a company overstates its use of AI. The allegation is that AI-enabled processes were materially contributing to financial performance, and that investors were not told enough about how, or about the risks this created.
Why it matters: The AI disclosure question is moving from ‘do you really use AI?’ to ‘how much of your performance depends on it?’. That is a harder question for boards to answer, and for underwriters to assess.
Sources: The D&O Diary’s post on LinkedIn · The D&O Diary · Law360
People behind the stories: Sarah Abrams, Kevin LaCroix, The D&O Diary
3) AI in the boardroom: when AI strategy becomes fiduciary risk
Shareholder litigation is now looking at the business decisions behind AI adoption, not just at the technology. Will Michener, David McIntosh, Joshua Talicska and Toby Shao of Ropes & Gray examine recent derivative suits involving Adobe, Microsoft and NVIDIA. The claims target the choice of training data, how the board oversaw it, and whether public AI commitments matched actual practice. The authors also flag new risks from agentic AI and retrieval-augmented generation, and set out steps boards can take to document reasonable oversight.
The latest example came this month. Shareholder Phil Rosen filed a derivative suit alleging that Apple’s leadership knowingly used copyrighted and unlicensed materials to develop its AI models. Nate French and Mason Dressler of Kennedys analyse the complaint in a guest post for The D&O Diary.
Why it matters: Derivative oversight claims can create significant Side A exposure, particularly where the company cannot indemnify the directors. AI governance, board minutes and reporting lines are therefore becoming underwriting questions.
Sources: Ropes & Gray’s post on LinkedIn · Ropes & Gray alert · Kennedys on the Apple suit (The D&O Diary)
People behind the stories: Will Michener, David McIntosh, Joshua Talicska, Toby Shao (Ropes & Gray), Nate French, Mason Dressler (Kennedys)
4) AI in the product: AppLovin and Baidu push the AI filing count to 24
Two more AI-related securities class actions were filed in mid-September. The first, filed on 14 September in the Southern District of New York, targets Baidu over claims that its AI-powered business would offset the decline in its legacy online-marketing revenue. The second, filed on 16 September in the Northern District of California, targets AppLovin. It alleges that executives said the company was ‘constantly improving’ its AI models while a new generative-AI video tool was ‘still a work in process’. The shares fell 19% on disappointing revenue.
As Kevin LaCroix counts it in The D&O Diary, that brings 2026 to 24 AI-related filings, nearly 14% of all new securities suits, against 16 for the whole of 2025.
Why it matters: A new kind of AI claim is emerging: not overstating AI, but failing to deliver the AI that was promised. Product roadmaps and development milestones are becoming disclosure risk.
Sources: Burkhard Fassbach’s post on LinkedIn · The D&O Diary (Kevin LaCroix) · AppLovin complaint notice
5) Podcast: Stephen Sills on building insurers through market cycles
Episode 7 of The D&O Diary Podcast Series is live. Kevin LaCroix and Sarah Abrams sit down with Stephen Sills, founder of Bowhead Specialty.
Sills traces how D&O grew from a $2–3 billion niche in the late 1990s into what he describes as a fragmented $40 billion market today. Where a handful of carriers once wrote $25 million lines, today roughly 75 carriers rarely put up more than $10 million on a single risk, facing a plaintiffs’ bar of nearly 500 firms.
His warning is about the industry’s perennial mistake: looking in the ‘rearview mirror’ when conditions are good, convinced that ‘this time is different’. His answer is discipline. Keep underwriting profit as the ‘north star’, and run the portfolio like ‘pots on the stove’: keep several classes warm and move capital to where margins are, rather than chasing volume in softening layers.
On underwriting itself, the job has moved from paper SEC filings to online data, reputational risk metrics and governance ratings. AI now does in minutes research that used to take a day, such as reviewing indemnification statutes, stress-testing coverage and triaging submissions. For Sills, though, algorithms should screen, not decide. He is especially cautious about AI and tech-exposed risks, where today’s valuation hype and rising litigation look uncomfortably like the late-1990s dot-com bubble.
The timing is apt. In August we reported US public D&O pricing’s first average increase in sixteen quarters.
Why it matters: A possible change in the cycle is precisely when insurers should resist chasing volume and re-test pricing, line size and accumulation exposure.
Sources: Sarah Abrams’ post on LinkedIn · Listen on The D&O Diary
People behind the stories: Stephen Sills (Bowhead Specialty), Kevin LaCroix, Sarah Abrams
Rest of the world
6) Europe: Marsh launches ‘Unity D&O’, a pan-European facility
Marsh has launched Unity D&O for non-financial European companies with revenues below €1 billion. It offers up to €15 million of primary capacity from a panel of six A-rated insurers and access to excess markets. It comes with a harmonised pan-European wording backed by local underwriting and claims support, plus optional extensions for EPL, crime and private-equity exposures.
It launches in France, Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden, with more countries to follow. Jean-Christophe Tessier, head of Marsh’s financial and professional practice in Europe, points to regulatory expectations, legal frameworks and claims practices that ‘vary significantly between jurisdictions’.
The open question is whether Marsh’s partnerships with local carriers that are not on the panel will hold. Those carriers may defend their accounts, which could create friction between Marsh and the wider market. This is also not the first time a broker has tried this strategy: Aon has launched European facilities in the past, with a more localised approach and mixed results depending on the country. Moving a programme from the open market into a facility is also harder in more transactional markets than in others.
Why it matters: A harmonised facility could intensify competition for European mid-market D&O and make wording differences more visible. The underwriting question is whether a common wording can operate consistently while local law, claims practice and distribution vary by country.
Sources: Marsh Europe’s post on LinkedIn · Commercial Risk
People behind the stories: Jean-Christophe Tessier, Marsh Europe
7) France: the liquidator comes first (Cass. com., 9 September 2026, n° 24-22.135, F-B)
In August we looked at the action en responsabilité pour insuffisance d’actif (article L. 651-2 of the Code de commerce). In September the Cour de cassation clarified who may bring it.
The action is open to the liquidator, the public prosecutor, and a majority of the creditors appointed as contrôleurs. The contrôleurs, however, can act only after a formal demand to the liquidator has gone unanswered. Their action is therefore subsidiary: once the liquidator has sued, the contrôleurs have no standing to act or to intervene, not even as ancillary parties. As ADSA Avocat summarises it, the ruling ‘consacre ainsi la primauté de l’action du liquidateur’.
Why it matters: The liquidator and the public prosecutor have direct standing. Creditors appointed as contrôleurs may act only on a subsidiary basis after an unanswered formal demand. This affects how D&O claims arise in French insolvencies and who the insurer may face.
Sources: ADSA Avocat’s post on LinkedIn · Commentary (Kohen Avocats) · Code de commerce, art. L. 651-2
8) France: WTW’s 2027 outlook, financial lines still soft but insurers look harder at risk control
On 23 September WTW France published its Note de conjoncture 2027, its annual view of the French corporate insurance market ahead of the 1 January renewals. Guillaume Deschamps, Head of FINEX France & Luxembourg at WTW, shared it on LinkedIn.
The headline is a soft market that should continue into 2027 barring major events. According to the coverage of the launch, ‘le cyber et les lignes financières restent eux aussi orientés à la baisse, avec des capacités importantes’.
The counterweight is selectivity. As WTW France CEO Nick Dussuyer put it, ‘une entreprise n’est plus uniquement jugée sur sa sinistralité passée mais aussi sur sa capacité à démontrer qu’elle agit sur ses risques futurs’. The note’s five key lessons also stress interconnected risks (climate, geopolitics, cyber, AI), data as a competitive advantage in placement, and critical dependencies such as suppliers and data centres.
Why it matters: French D&O buyers may still have room to negotiate on price and wording. For underwriters, WTW’s broader message suggests that differentiation will depend increasingly on the quality of risk management, including AI governance.
Sources: Guillaume Deschamps’ post on LinkedIn · WTW Note de conjoncture 2027 · DAF Mag · L’Argus de l’assurance
9) Germany: rescission for fraud in D&O, waiting for the BGH
A ruling by the Higher Regional Court (OLG) of Cologne on Arglistanfechtung, the insurer’s right to rescind a policy for fraudulent misrepresentation, continues to unsettle the German D&O market. As Patrick Hagen reported for Versicherungsmonitor, discussion at this month’s GVNW Symposium made clear that insurers, brokers and insureds all have to live with the uncertainty until the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) decides.
D&O trends featured prominently at the symposium, where Alexandra Braun and Michael Furtschegger of Allianz Commercial joined the panel discussions. The central issue is whether a fraudulent misrepresentation by the company or its signatory can bring down cover for everyone, including insured persons who knew nothing.
Why it matters: Innocent-insured protection, severability and non-rescindable Side A are wording questions in every market. The German D&O market is waiting for the BGH to clarify the issue.
Sources: Allianz Commercial’s post on LinkedIn (GVNW Symposium) · Versicherungsmonitor (paywall)
People behind the stories: Patrick Hagen, Alexandra Braun, Michael Furtschegger (Allianz Commercial), GVNW
10) Canada: Galaxy Digital class action certified in Ontario
In a decision dated 27 August, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice granted leave to pursue secondary-market misrepresentation claims and certified a class action against Galaxy Digital, CEO Mike Novogratz and former CFO Alex Ioffe. The claims concern disclosures about the company’s exposure to the Luna token and the TerraUSD stablecoin, which collapsed in 2022.
The judge wrote that the conclusion that the disclosures were misleading ‘is hard to deny’. The class covers purchasers between 17 May 2021 and 6 May 2022. Certification allows the claims to proceed; it does not determine whether any defendant made a misrepresentation or is liable. As Soheil Karkhanechi of SMK Law, which represents the investors, notes, the decision shows that ‘established securities-law disclosure principles apply equally’ to companies in emerging industries such as crypto.
Why it matters: Canada remains an important non-US venue for securities class actions, particularly for dual-listed issuers. Crypto-exposed issuers need programmes that respond in both jurisdictions.
Sources: Soheil Karkhanechi’s post on LinkedIn · Investment Executive
Takeaways
Shareholder voice is being re-routed, not removed. The SEC proposal would not eliminate activism. It could redirect pressure toward vote-no campaigns, proxy contests, litigation and company-specific bylaws, all of which can focus attention more directly on individual directors.
AI is now three D&O problems in court. The CVS, Apple, AppLovin and Baidu matters illustrate three distinct exposures: financial performance that depends on AI, board oversight of AI risks, and AI products that do not meet public expectations. By Kevin LaCroix’s count, 24 AI-related securities suits had been filed in 2026, compared with 16 in all of 2025.
Europe is harmonising, and litigating, at the same time. Marsh’s facility offers a harmonised wording across eight countries. France clarifies who may sue directors in an insolvency, while Germany awaits guidance from its highest civil court on rescission. Local law still shapes both claims and coverage.
Two markets, two directions. US public D&O pricing has shown an early sign of firming, while reporting on WTW’s outlook indicates that French financial lines remain soft into 2027. In both markets, outcomes will depend on the individual risk and the quality of its governance and controls.
Discipline is the real test of a turning market. Stephen Sills’ warning against underwriting through the rearview mirror is timely. With AI claims increasing and European capacity still abundant, insurers need to reassess pricing, line size and accumulation rather than chase volume.
This issue was first published on LinkedIn on 27 September 2026. Read and comment on LinkedIn, and subscribe below to receive future issues by email.